Recently, ex Minister Mentor Mr Lee Kuan Yew when interviewed expressed the view that Euro zone will collapse and cannot be saved.
On 31 May 2011, I also posted in thois forum similar views that Euro zone will disintegrate.
Cheers!
Dennis Ng
31 May 2011 The Euro Zone is artificially created by 16 countries choosing to "band together". The countries are very different, and some are financially very weak, eg. the PIGS.
The Financially weakest are ranked as follows:
1. Greece
2. Ireland
3. Portugal
4. Spain
5. Italy
So far, 3 out of the 4 PIGS are already in trouble, the good news is these 3 PIGs are "small", in terms of their economies as compared to the whole of Euro Zone.
However, Spain is ranked No. 4 and Italy is ranked No. 3 in terms of size of economy. In my opinion, it is just a matter of time Spain might get into trouble, and when that happens, I think the 2 Richest countries Germany and France might think twice about rescuing Spain and this might lead to the disintegration and break up of Euro Zone.
This is my prediction of what is likely to happen.
Below is an article on Europe Crisis.
Cheers!
Dennis Ng
Fixing Europe credit crisis made harder by the euro
By ROBERT SAMUELSON
IT has come to this. A year after rescuing Greece from default, Europe is staring into the abyss. The bailout has proved insufficient. Greece needs more money, and it can't borrow from private markets where it faces interest rates as high as 25 per cent. But Europe's governments are reluctant to advance more funds unless other lenders - banks, bondholders - absorb some losses by writing down their debts. This, however, would constitute a default, risking a broader banking crisis that might torpedo Europe's fragile recovery in France, Germany and elsewhere. There is no easy escape.
What's called a 'debt crisis' is increasingly a political and social crisis. Looming over the financial complexities is the broader question of the ability - or willingness - of weak debtor nations to endure growing hardship to service their massive government debts. Already, unemployment is at 14.1 per cent in Greece, 14.7 per cent in Ireland, 11.1 per cent in Portugal and 20.7 per cent in Spain. What are the limits of austerity? Steep spending cuts and tax increases do curb budget deficits; but they also create deep recessions, lowering tax revenues and offsetting some of the deficit improvement. Just how long this grinding process can continue is unclear. In Spain, the incumbent socialist party lost big in recent elections. Popular unrest persists in Greece amid signs of a 'resurgence of an anarchist movement' there and elsewhere.
Some causes of Europe's plight are well-known: the harsh recession following the 2008-2009 financial crisis; ageing populations coupled with costly welfare states. But there's also another less recognised culprit: the euro, the single currency now used by 17 countries. Launched in 1999, it aimed to foster economic and political unity. Economic growth would improve. Costly currency conversions would cease; money would flow smoothly across borders to the best profit opportunities. Using euros - and not marks or lira - Germans, Italians and others would increasingly consider themselves 'Europeans'. For a while, it seemed to succeed. In the euro's first decade, jobs in countries using the common currency increased by 16 million.
It was a mirage. The euro helped create the crisis and has made its resolution harder, as a new report from the International Monetary Fund shows. For starters, the euro fostered a credit bubble that led to booms in housing, borrowing and consumer spending. When each country had its own currency, the country's central bank regulated local interest rates and credit conditions. With the euro, the European Central Bank (ECB) assumed that job. But one policy didn't fit all: Interest rates suited to Germany and France were too low for 'periphery' countries (Greece, Ireland, Portugal and Spain).
'Financial markets' - private investors - compounded the problem by assuming that the euro's creation reduced risk. Weak countries would be protected by the strong. Money poured into the periphery countries. There was a huge compression of interest rates. In 1997, rates on 10-year Greek government bonds averaged 9.8 per cent compared to 5.7 per cent for similar German bonds. By 2003, Greek bonds fetched 4.3 per cent, just above the 4.1 per cent of German bonds.
'The markets failed. All this would not have occurred if banks in Germany and France had not lent so much,' says economist Desmond Lachman of the American Enterprise Institute. 'It was like the US housing market.'
Both American and European banks went overboard in relaxing credit standards. Now that the credit bubble has burst, the euro impedes recovery. One way countries revive from financial crises is by depreciating their currencies. This makes exports and local tourism cheaper, creating some job gains that cushion the ill effects of austerity elsewhere. But latched to the euro, Greece and other vulnerable debtors forfeit this safety valve.
Greece's debt is now approaching an unsustainable 160 per cent of its annual economy (gross domestic product). If it defaulted, investors might dump bonds of other weak debtors for fear that they too would default. That could send interest rates soaring and saddle European banks with huge losses. At the end of 2010, Europe's banks had about US$1.3 trillion of loans and investments - both governmental and private - in Greece, Ireland, Spain and Portugal, reports the Institute of International Finance, an industry research group. A banking crisis would imperil economic recovery.
So Europe is playing for time. It's struggling to delay any Greek default long enough for other vulnerable countries to demonstrate they can handle their debts. The very process makes the euro - contrary to original intent - a source of contention, as nations shift blame and costs to others. Given Europe's huge debts, even the holding action may fail. It may merely postpone a broader crisis. 'They may dodge this bullet,' says Mr Lachman, 'but not the next.' - The Washington Post Writers Group
Euro zone cannot be saved, says Mr Lee
Collapse will be painful, but one-tier Europe too hard to achieve, he says
By Rachel Chang & Teo Wan Gek
FORMER Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew believes the euro zone cannot be saved, although the collapse of the currency union will be 'a very painful business'.
Speaking at a dialogue yesterday to mark the seventh anniversary of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, he said European leaders will try very hard to keep the euro zone from collapsing as this would be 'an admission that their aspiration of one Europe is not achievable'.
'But I do not see it being saved. But they'll try and keep it going.'
He was speaking in response to a participant asking if Singapore would buy the bonds of debt-ridden European countries. The participant was referring to reports that Italy had asked China to buy its bonds.
Mr Lee said Singapore's gross domestic product is a fraction of the European Union's, and thus it is 'in no position to rescue the Europeans, nor do I think that buying their bonds will necessarily rescue them'.
He pointed to the currency union among the 17 EU countries as the problem. 'A fundamental problem of the euro is that it makes everybody, every European country, march to the same drummer whereas each country has its own tempo and you cannot expect the Greeks to march like the Germans, so the problem will not go away.
'Eventually, I'm not sure when because it would be an admission of the aspiration being out of reach, a two-tier Europe or even a three-tier Europe is possible but a one-tier Europe with different spending habits, thrift habits and discipline is too difficult to achieve.'
The euro came into existence in 1999 in the hope of increasing economic cooperation and growth in Europe, while shoring up the EU's presence on the world stage.
But as several euro zone countries face debt crises, the currency union has come under fire because it forces other European countries to bail out the troubled member nations, as well as denies policymakers the flexibility of monetary policy as a tool to fight recession.
Mr Lee also said he did not think the Chinese are interested in 'rescuing Europe for the sake of Europe. They're interested in buying euro bonds cheap and hope that it will give a good return'.
Recent reports estimate that up to one-quarter of China's reserves may be euro-denominated.
When moderator Kishore Mahbubani, dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, said that a strong EU would be in China's geopolitical interests, Mr Lee disagreed. He said: 'No, no, no. It's easier to deal with 27 weak European countries than to deal with 27 united European countries.'
rchang@sph.com.sg
wangekt@sph.com.sg